In Cave Creek, parcels tend to sit apart from one another, with fairways running through part of the area at Rancho Mañana Golf Club and open preserve and park land holding other stretches, along with a historic site and museum among the places recorded here. Owning here usually means owning ground as well as a structure: most of the homes for sale are detached houses on their own lots rather than attached units in a condo or townhouse development, so the walls, the roof and the land outside them are all on one deed. The West Valley Home Team works this market and knows how those parcels differ from one road to the next.
Cave Creek at a Glance
- ZIP codes in these listings
- 85331
- Typical asking price
- $1,000,000, middle half $699,743-$1,756,175 (median of 180 homes, excluding 41 land and other non-dwelling listings)
- Typical sold price
- $849,948, middle half $645,000-$1,250,000 (median of 629 home sales, excluding 47 land and other non-dwelling sales, past 12 months)
- Typical home
- 2,824 sq ft, middle half 2,106-3,578 (n=180) · 4 bed / 3 bath (medians, n=177)
- Typical days to sell
- 62 days (median of 629 closed home sales, past 12 months)
- Months of supply
- 3.4 (seller's market, homes only)
- Sold-to-list
- 97.7% of asking (median per home sale, n=629) · 5.7% sold above asking
- Data current as of
- August 2026
Homes on an acre or more in Cave Creek
An acre changes what you can do without asking anyone. The space is yours to use: room for equipment, for animals, for an outbuilding, or simply for distance from the nearest neighbor. That kind of parcel runs to a median of about $1.25 million across 172 sales, with a typical build year of 1999 and around 71 days between listing and closing. Roughly a third of these homes have a pool. Cave Creek Regional Park and Jewel of the Creek Preserve are both here, worth knowing about if the acreage you buy is more about elbow room than about land you intend to work. Expect a longer driveway, your own gates, and irrigation lines that are yours to trace and repair.
Browse all Homes on 1+ Acre in Cave Creek
Horse property in Cave Creek
Keeping animals at home rearranges the day. Feeding, turnout and the state of the fencing happen where you live rather than at the end of a drive across town, so the barn is part of the morning routine and the arena footing is something you notice on the way to the truck. Horse property in Cave Creek carries a median sale price of about $1.2 million across 137 sales, with a typical build year of 1998 and roughly 71 days on market. When you tour, walk the whole setup, not just the house: gates and latches, water lines to the troughs, the stalls, and where hay and shavings get stored and delivered. That infrastructure is yours to maintain year round.
View all Horse Property in Cave Creek
Homes with a pool in Cave Creek
The water is yours at whatever hour suits you, with nobody to book it around and nobody else in it. That is what a private pool changes about a house: a swim before work is a decision you make alone. In Cave Creek, this segment runs to a median of around $982,700 across 366 sales, with a typical build year of 1999 and about 59 days from listing to close. Nearly every home in this group has the pool itself, so what separates one listing from another is the shell, the deck and the equipment. Budget for the pump, the filter and the surface as part of the annual routine, and plan your yard around a feature that runs year-round.
View all Homes with a Pool in Cave Creek
Homes with a guest house in Cave Creek
The lot and everything on it are yours to change, and what you plant, park, extend or rebuild answers to the county rather than to a board of neighbors. A second dwelling on the parcel is one version of that freedom, and it comes at a median of about $1.35 million across 33 sales, closing in roughly 64 days. Thirty-three sales is a thin pool, so plan on watching listings over time rather than choosing between several at once. Look closely at how the casita is served: whether it shares systems with the main house or runs its own, and how it is metered. A separate roof, a separate entry and a separate set of fixtures all become part of what you maintain.
View all Homes with a Guest House in Cave Creek
What ownership here actually asks of you
The typical home here was built in 1999, with the middle half of the stock falling between 1995 and 2011. Ask which of the roof, the air handler and the water heater have been replaced and when, because at this age some of that work sits behind the house rather than ahead of it. The three-bedroom layout is the most common thing sold, at a median of $765,000 across 252 closed sales, and the largest single band of sale prices lands between $500,000 and $1 million. Tatum Ranch, Lone Mountain, Tonto Hills and Continental Mountain Estates are among the named communities recorded here. Some addresses fall inside an association with dues and governing documents and some sit in no subdivision at all, so establish which applies before you write on a specific listing. Either way, the driveway, the walls and the equipment on the pad are yours to keep running.
What buyers filter for in Cave Creek
A pool is on about half the homes here, and that group sells at a median of around $982,700 across 366 sales, so filtering for one narrows your search without emptying it. Schools are the other common filter, and here the listings themselves are what you are reading. About half report Black Mountain Elementary School, about a quarter Desert Willow Elementary School, and roughly one in six Lone Mountain Elementary School. At the middle level, most report Sonoran Trails Middle School, with small shares reporting Desert Mountain School and Black Mountain Elementary School. Those fields are typed by the listing agent, not pulled from district assignments, and boundaries shift, so confirm the current assignment for any specific address with the district directly.
What to verify before you commit
- Private well vs municipal water.
- Septic system condition and capacity.
- Wash or floodplain location on the lot.
- Horse property zoning and equestrian facilities condition.
- Well water quality and pump equipment age.
Buying in Cave Creek with The West Valley Home Team
The West Valley Home Team works Cave Creek closely enough to tell you what a given parcel actually comes with before you spend a Saturday on it, and to slow you down where a listing's details deserve a second look. If land is what you are after, an acre or more is one of the real decisions on this page, and it is the kind of purchase worth weighing carefully against the other ways of buying here. The aim is straightforward: a home that fits how you actually live, and a decision you feel settled about long after the paperwork is done.
